Plum Market

• Lucia by Pisoni Garys Pinot Noir 2022

  Red · California · 97 pts

  $79.99
  Go to store
• Hertelendy Signature Mountain Red Blend 2017

  Red · California · 97 pts

  $154.99typical $149.50
  4% above typical
  Go to store
• Fait-Main Cabernet Sauvignon Bettinelli Sleeping Lady Vineyard 2016

  Red · California · 97 pts

  $254.99
  Go to store
• Adamvs Quintvs Cabernet Sauvignon 2021

  Red · California · 97 pts

  $239.99
  Go to store
• Schafer-Frohlich Bockenauer Felseneck Riesling Spatlese 2023

  Dessert · Nahe · 96 pts

  $59.99
  Go to store
• Max Ferd. Richter Riesling Spätlese Veldenzer Elisenberg 2023

  White · Mosel · 96 pts

  $37.99typical $32.99
  15% above typical
  Go to store
• Benmar Into the Fog 2023

  Red · Oregon · 96 pts

  $39.97typical $43.97
  9% below typical
  Go to store
• Pewsey Vale Museum Reserve The Contours Riesling 2014

  White · Eden Valley · 96 pts

  $39.99
  Go to store
• Hartford Court Pinot Noir Land's Edge Vineyards Sonoma Coast 2023

  Red · California · 96 pts

  $39.97
  Go to store
• Tenute del Cabreo Il Borgo Toscana IGT 2020

  Red · Tuscany · 96 pts

  $54.97
  Go to store
• Alzinger Ried Hollerin Smaragd Wachau Riesling 2023

  White · Wachau · 96 pts

  $64.99
  Go to store
• Quinta do Vallado 20 Year Old Tawny Port NV (500ml)

  Fortified · Douro · 96 pts

  $75.99typical $59.97
  27% above typical
  Go to store
• Melka Majestique Paderewski Vineyard Syrah 2019

  Red · North Coast · 96 pts

  $99.99typical $103.50
  3% below typical
  Go to store
• Antinori Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon Townsend 2021

  Red · California · 96 pts

  $139.97typical $149.00
  6% below typical
  Go to store
• Chateau Roquefort Blanc 2024

  White · Bordeaux · 95 pts

  $16.99
  Go to store
• Graham Beck Ultra Brut Methode Cap Classique 2017

  Sparkling · Western Cape · 95 pts

  $36.99typical $31.97
  16% above typical
  Go to store
• Clos Cibonne Tibouren Rosé Cuvée Prestige Caroline 2024

  Rosé · Côtes de Provence · 95 pts

  $59.99
  Go to store
• Voerzio Martini Barolo Cerequio 2019

  Red · Piedmont · 95 pts

  $104.99typical $119.97
  12% below typical
  Go to store
• J.M. Labruyere Page Blanche Blanc de Blancs Grand Cru Verzenay NV

  Sparkling · Champagne · 95 pts

  $91.99
  Go to store
• Tempier Cuvée Cabassaou Bandol 2023

  Red · Provence · 95 pts

  $152.99
  Go to store
• Quintarelli Passito Amabile del Cerè 2007

  Dessert · Veneto · 95 pts

  $309.99
  Go to store
• Chateau Livran 2020

  Red · Medoc · 94 pts

  $20.99typical $14.99
  40% above typical
  Go to store
• MY FAVORITE NEIGHBOR Harvey and Harriet Red Blend 2023

  Red · California · 94 pts

  $19.97
  Go to store
• Pax The Bench Clements Hills Syrah 2023

  Red · California · 94 pts

  $34.99typical $29.99
  17% above typical
  Go to store
• Pascal & Nicolas Reverdy Sancerre Les Coutes 2025

  White · Loire · 94 pts

  $36.99typical $34.96
  6% above typical
  Go to store
• Couly-Dutheil Clos De L'Echo 2019

  Red · Loire Valley · 94 pts

  $34.99
  Go to store
• Mullineux Syrah 2022

  Red · Swartland · 94 pts

  $41.99
  Go to store
• Raventos i Blanc Conca del Riu Anoia Brut Textures de Pedra 2020

  Sparkling · Catalonia · 94 pts

  $52.99
  Go to store
• Keenan Zinfandel 2021

  Red · California · 94 pts

  $44.99
  Go to store
• Casale del Giglio Mater Matuta 2019

  Red · Lazio · 94 pts

  $74.99
  Go to store
• Château de la Font du Loup Châteauneuf-du-Pape Le Puy Rolland 2022

  Red · Rhone · 94 pts

  $61.99
  Go to store
• Quinta De Cabriz Colheita Selecionada Red 2023

  Red · DOC Dão · 93 pts

  $12.99
  Go to store
• Evening Land Chardonnay Eola-Amity Hills Seven Springs Vineyard 2023

  White · Oregon · 93 pts

  $41.97typical $33.98
  24% above typical
  Go to store
• Tolaini Chianti Classico Vallenuova 2020

  Red · Tuscany · 93 pts

  $24.97
  Go to store
• Pascal & Nicolas Reverdy Terre de Maimbray Sancerre Rosé 2025

  Rosé · Loire · 93 pts

  $31.99typical $29.99
  7% above typical
  Go to store
• Domaine de la Bastide Blanche Bandol Rouge 2021

  Red · Languedoc-Roussillon · 93 pts

  $34.99typical $31.47
  11% above typical
  Go to store
• Grgich Hills Estate Napa Valley Chardonnay 2023

  White · California · 93 pts

  $39.99
  Go to store
• Casaloste Chianti Classico Riserva 2019

  Red · Tuscany · 93 pts

  $49.99
  Go to store
• LeClerc Briant Blanc de Meunier Premier Cru Brut Zero NV

  Sparkling · Champagne · 93 pts

  $164.99
  Go to store
• Torre Zambra Montepulciano d'Abruzzo Madia 2021

  Red · Abruzzo · 92 pts

  $13.97
  Go to store
• Domaine Houchart Côtes de Provence Rosé NV

  Rosé · Côtes de Provence · 92 pts

  $19.99
  Go to store
• Davis Bynum River West Vineyard Chardonnay 2023

  White · California · 92 pts

  $15.97
  Go to store
• Jean Leon Vinya Le Havre Cabernet Sauvignon Reserva 2020

  Red · Catalonia · 92 pts

  $41.99
  Go to store
• Frog's Leap Napa Valley Merlot 2023

  Red · California · 92 pts

  $46.97
  Go to store
• Ixsir El Ixsir Red 2017

  Red · Batroun · 92 pts

  $69.99
  Go to store
• Remirez de Ganuza Vina Coqueta 2015

  Red · Rioja · 92 pts

  $59.99
  Go to store
• Ziata Mia Madre Red 2018

  Red · California · 92 pts

  $75.00typical $91.51
  18% below typical
  Go to store
• Château Peynaud-Bagnac 2020

  Red · Bordeaux · 91 pts

  $13.97
  Go to store

Per bottle, before shipping and tax. Typical price is the median other stores charge for the same vintage and bottle size. A deal is 20% or more below typical.